THE 36 BEST Pizza Restaurants near Youngstown, NY - 2024 Restaurantji (2024)

Customers` Favorites

“So here’s my take on Grandma D’s. 1st of all Niagara County y’all better step your game up! The food down to the customer service out of this world! I ordered a steak n cheese sub which is absolutely amazing! Great roll, real steak! So good! They threw me in a piece of sesame seed chicken pizza and that was bananas! Grandma D’s is straight fire!“

Customers` Favorites

“In the vast ocean of Western New York pizzerias, Main Street Pizzeria stands as a lighthouse for those of us questing for that perfect slice. The secret to their standout pizza? It begins with the crust - golden, with just the right crunch to softness ratio, it's a foundation strong enough to bear the weight of any topping yet delicate enough to meld seamlessly into every bite. The staff at Main Street Pizzeria are not just employees; they are custodians of quality, ensuring every visit is as welcoming as it is satisfying. Add to this mix their commitment to quality ingredients, and you have a recipe for success. Whether it's the vibrant sauce, the perfectly melted cheese, or the fresh, flavorful toppings, Main Street Pizzeria knows that quality is not just an ingredient but the main ingredient. From the moment you step in, it's clear: this isn't just another pizza place. It's a community staple where every slice is crafted with care, and every visit leaves you planning the next. If you're in search of a great pizza, look no further. Main Street Pizzeria doesn't just make pizza; they make memories, one slice at a time.“

Customers` Favorites

“We visited Camp Cataract since it was recommended to us during our recent visit to Niagara Falls. It is a great bar with a cool vibe, delicious drinks and awesome people. The owners, Brian and Courtney, treated us like family and made sure we had a great time. Kyle was an amazing server as well! In fact, we had such a good time the first night, we came back again the next night! I highly recommend visiting Camp Cataract when you're in town!“

Customers` Favorites

“I recommend everything about the Grist. From the moment you walk in to the beautiful decor and the entire atmosphere. The friendly helpful staff who will answer any questions regarding the drinks and menu. The menu covers all types of foods and they are totally willing to alter for people's allergies etc. They change the menu choices sporadically and everything is delicious . It is truly an enjoyable dining experience. Our Christmas Party was in the loft upstairs and the attention to detail and the food was amazing. The Loft itself is a perfect place for smaller functions - cozy and intimate. The owners are the nicest people I have ever met.“

Customers` Favorites

“Love this winery and with the Barrelhead's limited menu, you know the food is going to be quality goodness. Service is always friendly and unassuming and the tours I've tried every food item but my favourite is definitely the blueberry and peach salad. Their pizza's are outstanding and I hope that one day, I'll be able to buy their ginger beer as a 6 pack ?“

Customers` Favorites

“We stopped in for takeout subs. It had been a while since l'd been there. I had an Eggplant parm sub (beyond superior), and the boss had a breaded chicken sub (which l ate 1/3 of - equally wicked!!). Both were fantastic. Who has tins of pop for 90¢? If value for the money was the only reason you visit, you wouldn't be disappointed. If you want to base your custom on food quality and flavour.....same story. There is a reason they've been here for so long.Great job!Vegetarian options: The Eggplant parm was very good. Crispy and well "sauced" - delish!!!“

Customers` Favorites

“Food and drinks were great. We arrived at 4:30 and didn't have reservations, so we had to sit at the bar, which was pleasant. We found it odd that there were plenty of tables available during our entire visit, but we weren't able to get a table. The bar was completely filled with customers when we left. I recommend making reservations.“

Customers` Favorites

“George's is the best in the falls, sauce is fantastic, crust is fantastic, and the toppings are generous.Staff is always very polite, wait times aren't horrible, and it's always fresh. The prices are also reasonable. George's is the only place we go for pizza.“

Customers` Favorites

“A warm classic Italian restaurant! Waitress was friendly and attentive. Food was delivered with traditional covers to maintain food warmth and food temperature. Lasagna and sauce was excellent as was the spinach ravioli. A must go to after shopping at the outlet mall!“

Customers` Favorites

“I like to visit local places when I travel. I came across this place when I was taking the backroads to my hotel. I immediately knew I had to try it out . Me and the wife had a great conversation while we waited . Franca is awesome , she enjoys telling her story and watching her make the pizzas while she does. The pizza was amazing and the Caprese Salad was so fresh !!5 starts all the way !!!“

Customers` Favorites

“Best Pizza in town. We loved tanduri paneer pizza and garlic bread. It gave is feeling of India. If you are in Niagra falls and craving Indian style paneer pizza with some customized special masala do visit this location. Owner is extremely helpful and polite person.“

Customers` Favorites

“Had the beef dip sandwich, it came with auju and a mound of fries. Couldn't say no to the carrot cheese cake thingy either. Needless to say, a delightful staff and wonderful food. If they could change one thing about the place, have Caddyshack playing on at least one TV at all times. 5 stars“

Customers` Favorites

“Just got back from picking up the chicken parmigiana bomber sub. OMG was it AMAZING!!! I planned on sharing with my husband but it was so large I shared with not only hubby but 2 of my sons. I drove from Tonawanda to try it & it was still warm when I got home. Very friendly bartender & owner. Menu is awesome & I def recommend stopping in. You will NOT be disappointed!! I’d give 10 stars if I could. Great place. Awesome word. Welcoming staff.“

Customers` Favorites

“Local favorite. Probably best to order in advance for pickup. Wings take 20 minutes. They have square pizzas with thicker crust than a "NY" pizza and sell by the slice. If you come after the lunch rush, you get the leftovers. I made the mistake of grabbing a slice of cheese (all that was left) and wings. The slice was incredible, I mean one of the better pizza slices I have had, and I went back for another but they were cleaned out. No more slices until dinner rush. The interior is basic as most folks get the food to go. Wings were good. Not memorable but would be remembered as a good solid wing. Pretty happy with this place.“

Customers` Favorites

“Great breakfast! Classic sports bar and restaurant for any time of day. Nice breakfast menu that is far more reasonably priced than any of the places in town - and yet this is less than a 15 minute walk from the center of town.Dietary restrictions: Keto friendlyLow carb friendlyPaleo friendlyCarnivore friendlyParking: Nice open lot right at the door.“

Customers` Favorites

“They have the best wings, hands down.Tried their gluten-free pizza, and I did not like it.Originally, I wanted their cauliflower pizza, but they were out of stock.I have tried this before, and it was great.Dietary restrictions: For those looking for gluten-free pizza crust, I would advise the cauliflower crust instead.Wheelchair accessibility: Not wheelchair friendly.It's just a manual pull door and not extra wide.“

Customers` Favorites

“As many people may agree with me(because of the amount of food getting ordered/picked up), Favorites Pizzeria is an amazing restaurant. They provide SO many options in every food, especially the pizza. All the food is very cheap and feels like a steal. They provide options for many diets and it tastes wonderful. The service is great and the staff are incredibly friendly.Vegetarian options: The pizza and food provide veggie options while having it on lots of their dishes.Parking: The parking is great and usually has many open spots that are wide enough for many cars.Wheelchair accessibility: Favorites does provide accessibility for wheelchairs with open space and low tables.“

Customers` Favorites

“I surprised my husband on a Saturday evening in July for a nice birthday dinner at Casa Antica! Wow were we pleasantly surprised. I got the chicken Parmesan and I highly recommend it! The chicken was perfectly crispy and so flavorful, topped with the thickest layer of mozzarella cheese I have ever had on a chicken parm! To make it even better, our lovely waiter brought out this amazing spread of bread and dips! It was a great touch and the bread and dips were so good that it left me wanting more! I highly recommend checking out this lovely place in the quaint town of Lewiston! The patio was lovely for a warm July night, and the wait staff were nothing but wonderful, exceptional service, and very attentive to all our needs! We will definitely be returning here again for another amazing dining experience!“

Customers` Favorites

“No visit to Niagara on the lake is complete without visiting Nina. The croissants are melt in your mouth. Other pastries and baked goods are super delicious. The strawberry and pistachio gelato were awesome. Our other favourites are the Banana loaf, and shortbread cookies. The service here is warm and always welcoming. Bravo?“

Customers` Favorites

“Our welcome and service throughout our meal was excellent. I had pretty high hopes when I saw the menu but I confess I was a little disappointed. My pizza was undercooked and the dough was raw in the middle, I got really bloated afterwards. My wife's food was great though and she was really happy. Definitely would recommend the focaccia - although it's not an authentic focaccia it is still very delicious.“

Customers` Favorites

“Edit: we came specially from Toronto to just eat this pizza...and they had even better service, best pizza deals and the taste wow...thanks AnirutO ooo myyyy gooodnesss.... I have never ate anything like this before.We tried their Uber eats $13.99 for BOGO shawarma pizza and can't say enough... It's totally amazing.The staff Lissel & Basil made it the best ever.Now Everytime I'm in Niagara, this will be the MUST PLACE TO GO.“

Customers` Favorites

“Always good pizza from petes that's why it's on my pizza mix list lolParking: The staff is friendly and pete remembers the customers . I'm curious to try it they have a deep dish pizza 24 hours notice I really need to try it some time“

Customers` Favorites

“The missing family restaurant in NOTL. This is an independent chain menu type of restaurant. Burger and fries, pizza, fish and chips and some salads. This place has that family restaurants done right vibe although not every tv needs to have sports on it, bit of a negative there. The food was fresh not frozen. It was middle of the road flavour. The pizza was wood fired but the dough was a bit flat in flavour, didn’t have that tang from a 24hr rise a good wood fire dough needs. Way better than any chain pizza you will ever find. Like I said, middle of the road. The staff were amazing and friendly. Well trained like everywhere in NOTL, I left a large a well earned large tip. Give this place a try if you want to go out and get something new but familiar.Vegetarian options: Yup. I didn’t really pay attention but there were salads.Dietary restrictions: They have a large Gluten Free menu. The section is posted on the website.Parking: Large parking lot.Kid-friendliness: Absolutely. Tons of kids there when we went. Didn’t even mind when our kid spilled her juice. Thanks again.Wheelchair accessibility: It’s wheelchair ramped in the front. Look like there were large enough laneways to get through. Most tables are on the floor level and there is a decent sized patio. There are a couple of high barstool tables but most are average height. I never went to the washroom.“

Customers` Favorites

“Great little sports bar - hidden gem!Just came in for pizza and wings and was not disappointed! Cup and char was great! Wings were big! Blue cheese was chunky which I love and most places don’t have it like that 10/10Service was great as well! Must try spot in the falls!“

“Awesome food, honest relatable staff who just provide what they’re advertising. Actual good quality food, not something you find so easily especially for this price point. Over the last few years of ordering there. I can confidently say the food has been consistent. Never a night where it tasted off or felt rushed. Going somewhere and knowing when the grease must be old or the cook called off. I have never had that experience at the great foodini. The pizza (specifically the ghost pepper crust) French onion soup. The Jamaican jerk quesadilla. All things I look forward too and know will be good every time.“

Customers` Favorites

“Amazing food and service. They even gave me an extra plate so I could feed my 8 month old. It's the little things that countKid-friendliness: They were so kind to my daughter and were laughing an playing with her. They also made sure we had an extra plate to feed her“

Customers` Favorites

“Absolutely delicious pizza and wings! This food exceeded my expectations so much that I wish I could take this place home with me! They have a pool table and a seating area to accommodate everybody including kids! Amazing food. Great friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere. Definitely check this place out!“

Customers` Favorites

“Best pizza around. Beautiful, cute, unique place. Awesome customer service. Craving their pizza again already and I just had it. Going to order again as soon as I get paid. I do recommend to all my friends and family.Parking: Plenty of parking availableKid-friendliness: This looks kid friendly for sure.Wheelchair accessibility: I do believe this is wheelchair accessible. No steps or ramps.“

Customers` Favorites

“Just ordered for the first time and me and my husband was extremely satisfied with the food . The pizza was so good! The crust is so nice and light and the ingredients are fresh. I found the staff to be super friendly and welcoming and I had no problems with wait times as others have said. This is much better than most other take-out pizza places in my opinion and I will definitely be ordering from here again. I highly suggest giving it a try “

“Great pizza, great wings, friendly staff and quick turnaround times! My kind of place! I am constantly dissapointed in most of my pizza and wing buying experiences. I’ve decided this is strictly my/our go to for pizza nights. Always good, hot and service with a smile. Definitely check out YNPC on portage in N.F“

Customers` Favorites

“This is a place to eat from pizza is good and on point very good crust and the wings are cooked and sauced just right it was me and my families first time eating from this restaurant and it was good we will definitely be eating from this restaurant again they have a family of new “

Customers` Favorites

“This was a really fun get away for our family! The rooms are cozy and cute, but could use a little updating and upkeep. The service was great. We didn't have an issue with waiting to get in for the buffet but I guess we had good timing on that. The fine dining restaurant Barnwood was pretty good but pricey, working out some kinks as they've only been open a few months. We loved the Watering hole for lunch, snacks and drinks. The water park itself was great, and the lines not too bad when we went. Our five year old loved the Magi quest and arcade. We are looking forward to returning.“

Customers` Favorites

“* Staff is very friendly, polite, helpful and always smiling. A few times when I went in to pick up my orders after a tired long day - with their cheeriness I came out with a smile ?* Place is always clean.* My orders are great - they make what and how I want it. ( some other places I've went was not happy & never went back nor recommended)* The amount of orders we've bought from this store we could actually fill a room 'full' of their empty boxes (yes, not kidding ?)* This store is more than a 5+++Vegetarian options: Check out their menu(s) also check the nutrition menu you will find lots of information - right down to the calories ?Build your pizza your way.Dietary restrictions: You can always pick and choose what items you want so do so according to your dietary restriction(s). Check their nutrition menu there's lots of info right down to the calories ?Parking: This Domino's is on a corner of two main streets. It's in a mini mall with shared parking. With parking in front of store, as well as further left of the parking lot - good size for mini mall. If by chance it happened to be full there is more free parking in the back so you can run in to pick up your order pizza/etc ? There's also a residential street behind.Kid-friendliness: The store setup is great if you go in to get your food with your kids as they can't really get into anything ?Wheelchair accessibility: There is a ramp to get from the parking lot to the sidewalk of the where the stores are, there is a disability permit spot (one that I know of is closer in front of Silks restaurant)....doors to stores not sure if any has auto push button as I didn't check - but there are always helpful people around to help if need be.“

“Our sales team came for dinner at Gallo and loved it! We had meatballs, pizza (amaz!) pasta with Amatriciana sauce and my absolute favorite eggplant - a MUST HAVE for any eggplant lover! Delicious food from beginning to end! Service is just as outstanding as the food. We cannot wait to go back!“

Customers` Favorites

“Its a pre-made pizza place. The pizzas are pre-made and ready to serve from heated storage. Price is reasonable compared to the competition. The pizza quality is ok....for the price. Its a take out only. The person I had serving me had excellent customer service. Made my day !Parking: Its located in a plaza so plenty of parking“

Customers` Favorites

“We wanted a good sub so we tried Franks for the first time. We were welcomed very warmly by the owner who helped us with the menu. We decided on a steak sub deluxe and a deluxe cold cut. These subs were very large , fresh, delicious and filling. I very much recommend this place and look forward to visiting again to try the pizza and wings.“